In short
- Ring your top bidders with a personal thank-you.
- Thank pledgers most warmly of all: a pledge is a pure gift.
- For anyone who pledged about £1,000 or more, make it a phone call, not an email.
- Keep the call to thanks. Ask for nothing and let the relationship grow from there.
- A thank-you call is good manners with a long-term payoff. Large trials have not shown it lifts repeat giving by itself.
Knowing how to thank donors after a charity auction means treating the two kinds of givers differently. The people who won lots bought something. The people who pledged gave outright, and they are the ones worth a phone call.
What follows is what I advise after the auctions and pledges I run, plus general guidance from the sources linked. It is not legal or tax advice.
Who should you thank after a charity auction, and how?
Thank everyone, but not in the same way. Ring the top bidders, phone the larger pledgers, and send the rest a prompt, specific message. The more someone gave without receiving anything, the more personal the thank-you should be.
My guide to thanking donors covers the close of the night and the week-one message that goes to everybody. This post is the layer above it: the handful of people who deserve more than a mailing.
| Who | What they did | Suggested thank-you |
|---|---|---|
| Top bidders | Bought lots at the top of the room | A personal phone call |
| Pledgers at about £1,000 or more | Gave outright, nothing in return | A phone call, not an email |
| Smaller pledgers | Gave outright | A personal email or note, by name |
| Everyone else | Came, bid, or gave through the night | The week-one thank-you to all |
The £1,000 line is mine. Set your own with your committee, and write it down before the night so nobody is arguing about it afterwards.
Why does a pledger deserve a phone call?
A pledger gave money and received nothing back, so a pledge is the purest gift of the evening. Someone who gives that way, expecting nothing, can become a regular donor, which is why the thank-you should be a call and not a form message.
I thank the pledgers especially, because pledging is, in my words, “a sheer act of generosity”. A bidder at least goes home with a lot. HMRC’s guidance on what charities can claim makes the same distinction in tax terms: only voluntary gifts qualify, and payments received in return for goods do not.
For anyone who pledged about £1,000 or more, I first thought a personal email would do. On reflection a phone call is more fitting, precisely because they get nothing for that money. Treat them as people who could give your charity a great deal over a long period, because some of them could.
Top bidders deserve a call too. They paid the most for the night’s lots, and a winner thanked by a human is easier to ring again. How you handle the money side is in collecting payment.

What do you say on a thank-you call?
Say who you are, thank the person by name for a specific thing, tell them one concrete thing the money will do, and stop. The call is not a pitch. It is a short, warm conversation that leaves them feeling seen.
This is general advice, not a script I run. A short outline:
- Who calls. A trustee, the chair or the person who invited them, not the finance officer. The caller should have a relationship.
- Open with thanks. “Thank you for what you gave on Saturday” beats a speech.
- One real outcome. Name what the money pays for, using the net figure, not a vague “your support means so much”.
- No ask. Do not mention next year’s event or another gift. The call earns the right to ask later, once.
- Listen. Note why they gave and what they said, and put it in the donor record.
- Voicemail. Leave a short thank-you and your name. A message still counts.
Does a thank-you call after a charity auction bring donors back?
Not by itself. A large randomised trial found no effect on repeat giving, so a call is courtesy first. For a handful of major pledgers, courtesy is a good enough reason to pick up the phone.
The study, by Anya Samek and Chuck Longfield, was reported in the Chronicle of Philanthropy in January 2020. It randomised more than half a million first-time donors at 70 public television stations and one national nonprofit. Calls that discussed the gift’s impact and made no ask did not change repeat giving, whatever the size of the first gift.
A July 2026 review on UK Fundraising argues the null result may reflect generic, transactional scripts, and notes that stronger claims rest on practitioner experience and single case studies. It does not split results by donor size. I found no study of a gala pledger who gave four figures, so I make no promise about what a call will do.
My rule follows from that. Do not ring forty people and call it a retention strategy. Ring the few who gave most, mean it, and judge the result by whether they want to hear from you again.
Can you phone them, and what about Gift Aid?
You can phone someone to thank them, but keep the call to thanks. The ICO’s April 2026 news on the charity soft opt-in describes it as covering electronic mail: emails, texts and social media messages. It does not describe calls.
The ICO says its guidance on live calls covers calls made for direct marketing purposes, and is under review. So a call that only thanks, asks nothing and promotes nothing is the safest shape. Check with whoever owns data protection, and see my donor data checklist. The Fundraising Regulator’s rule 1.1.2 also asks you to avoid unreasonably intruding on privacy, putting undue pressure on a person, or being unreasonably persistent.
Gift Aid is the other thing a thank-you call tends to touch. A pledge is a gift, so it can qualify where the donor is eligible and has made a valid declaration. A lot bought at auction is a purchase. HMRC’s Gift Aid notes (paragraph 3.40.8) say only the amount paid above the item’s value can be treated as a gift, and only where the bidder knew that value when they bid.
If a pledger’s declaration went missing on the night, HMRC’s declarations guidance allows it to be given verbally, as long as you send written confirmation, and says declarations can be backdated. Records are the point: keep either an audio recording or a record of when the confirming letter went out. Then claim, because HMRC’s claim guide sets four years from the end of the financial period you received the donation in, as at November 2026.
Balance the asks before you thank anyone
A warm call cannot rescue an evening where guests felt fleeced. If people were asked for money every fifteen minutes, one ask after another, many will not come back next year.
So the thank-you starts before the night. Leave guests mostly alone during dinner, and run the asks in a sensible order: silent auction, a game, the live auction, then the pledge. If a lot of fundraising came before the pledge, I am happy with a watered-down one, with a single tier and a smaller target.
My test is simple: sit in a guest’s chair and ask how you would feel being asked this many times. If you feel fine, the plan is sound. If not, rethink it. The point is not to put people off coming back. Review all of this properly at your event debrief.
When is it worth hiring a charity auctioneer for this?
The calls themselves are yours to make. A small supper where the committee knows every guest does not need a professional for this, and a trustee’s call will land better than mine.
A professional earns the fee on the night, because the follow-up depends on it. A live pledge can be frantic: many hands go up at once, and every one has to be captured, and paid, quickly. If a pledge is missed, no call can thank the person. I plan for that with the committee, including how a live pledge is structured and who is on the volunteer team.
If you want that groundwork done as part of my services, have your date, room size and running order ready, and call me on 07596 851647.

Kevin Durham
Charity auctioneer & event host
















